Power your Marketing.

P&C Insurance Direct Marketing: The Art of Acquiring and Retaining Customers

Michelle Peel

Property and Casualty insurance marketers are responsible for acquiring and retaining customers. Easy, right? Wrong. Very few new customers are entering the P&C insurance market. A recent Bain & Company report showed only 2% new customer growth this year. Simply put, one insurer’s acquisition success will be another insurer’s retention failure.

Most acquired customers are people who switch from a competitor. So when it comes to direct mail, it’s all about customer acquisition. Advertising spend directly correlates with customer acquisition rates. The top performers in acquisition spend 50% more than average on advertising per customer. Of the nearly four billion pieces of insurance direct mail last year and nearly two billion pieces sent by P&C insurance companies during the first six months of 2014, 98% of  direct mail efforts were focused on acquisition compared to just 2% for retention according to Comperemedia.

The art of successful P&C insurance direct marketing campaigns is identifying the contrast between those focused on acquisition and those focused on retention, and then using skillful strategies for each approach.

Acquisition Mail

According to survey results from Bain & Company, customers buy home and auto insurance primarily based on price. Two-thirds of respondents price shop at more than one provider, while 84% identify themselves as price-sensitive customers.

P&C insurance acquisition direct marketing campaigns should focus on price incentives to achieve results.

Retention Mail

Happy, loyal customers will stay longer, buy more products with their primary insurance carrier and make more referrals to friends and colleagues.

P&C insurance retention direct marketing campaigns should focus on personalized and targeted offers sent to selected customers expressing appreciation of their loyalty.

Best Practices

We identify with the advice from Bain & Company, “Invest in “wowing” customers,” and recommend following these best practices to make your P&C insurance acquisition and retention direct mail efforts stand out from the competition, resulting in increased gross response rates (GRR):

  • Affix an instant access quote card or price savings incentive card to your mailpiece. Cards get noticed and can be kept for future reference.
  • Personalize and target your offer so the customer feels they are receiving it in appreciation of their business.
  • Promote customer-focused offerings like access to 24-hour customer service.
  • Engage in cross-channel marketing by directing respondents to your website to claim the cost savings offer.

Direct mail continues to help insurance companies grow their business, so consider these trends and best practices to create more successful P&C insurance acquisition and retention campaigns. You will appeal to the price-sensitive prospects and customers as well as increase retention among your most loyal customers. Contact us to learn more about our direct mail services and how they can serve your needs in the insurance industry.

link https://www.iwco.com/blog/2014/07/25/p-and-c-insurance-direct-marketing-trends/
Michelle Peel


Michelle Peel

As Marketing and Corporate Communications Manager, Michelle enhances the customer experience for our clients by keeping her finger on the pulse of key consumer trends, new vertical market developments, and competitor insights that impact their business. A graduate of Elizabethtown College with more than 20 years of direct marketing experience, she brings the “make it happen” attitude to IWCO Direct every day. She is a dedicated Pittsburgh Steelers fan who enjoys shopping, crafting, and spending time with her family.

More Posts by Michelle


Subscribe via email to our Stevie® and Feedspot award-winning blog and get a fresh post delivered weekly to your inbox. We promise to keep it interesting, but you can easily unsubscribe if we don’t.

keyboard_arrow_upBack to top